Policy: Brexit
Deglobalisation in disguise?
Danyal Arnold, Shania Bhalotia and Swati Dhingra
Brexit means that UK exporters of services now face more red tape and fewer opportunities.
A central vision of proponents of Brexit was that unshackled from the rules and regulations of Brussels, the UK would forge new trade deals, reconnect with fast-growing markets and recharge its historical comparative advantages in sectors such as finance, law, education and life sciences - the backbone of its modern services-driven economy.
We have assessed what Brexit has meant for the ability of UK businesses to export their services abroad. The short answer? Services exporters now face higher trading costs, more red tape and fewer opportunities. The country remains a services powerhouse, but services exports have been underperforming due to Brexit barriers. What's more, the promised "Global Britain" pivot to markets beyond the European Union has not materialised.
Services account for around 80% of UK GDP and over half of all UK exports. Tradable services have been key drivers of economic growth. Yet the impact of Brexit on services has received far less attention than the impact on goods. This is partly because barriers to trade in services are less tangible than those for goods: there are no queues at Dover when a services deal collapses.
Measuring the unseen: Brexit barriers to services trade
Barriers to services trade don't show up as taxes or duties or tariffs that are easy to quantify. Rather, they come from divergent national rules and regulations - differences that deep trade agreements seek to overcome through provisions such as common rules or regulatory equivalence. To understand how Brexit has affected UK services, we need to measure these regulatory barriers.
We have built a novel dataset that captures the barriers from Brexit at a granular level - looking at country-service pairs to determine which UK services exports are affected and by how much. Barriers include restrictions such as Germany requiring lawyers to have European Economic Area or Swiss qualifications to provide certain legal services.
Far from unleashing the UK's global services potential, Brexit has slowed it down
With a comprehensive set of barriers, we can track how export patterns changed before and after Brexit. Growth of UK's worldwide services exports has slowed and diverged substantially from growth of other exporters in the most affected services (see the left-hand panel of Figure 1), while the least affected services have performed much more similarly to other exporters (right-hand panel of Figure 1).
One of the key political arguments for Brexit was that the UK could shift its focus globally and gain in world markets. Yet worldwide UK exports have underperformed by 4% to 5% in value - around £19.3bn to £24.1bn annually.
Figure 1: Growth in services exports of the UK and the world, by intensity of Brexit barriers
Source: Authors' calculations using OECD-WTO Balanced Trade in Services (BaTIS) data. Trade values are in US dollars and deflated using the World Bank's GDP deflator for the United States, and normalising exports to 1 in 2015 for the UK and the rest of the world.
A substantial hit to EU services exports
Next, we dig deeper by doing a like-for-like comparison of UK exports to EU for a service and time with exports of the same service at the same time for other exporter-importer pairs in our data.
Figure 2: Event study for relative effects of Brexit barriers
Figure 2 shows the growth in UK services exports to the EU, with barriers (in red) or without barriers (in black). Growth was highly similar to that of other countries' exports or those of the UK to countries outside the EU, before 2020, just prior to the post-Brexit trading rules coming into effect. After the barriers from the new arrangements went up in 2021, UK exports in services where there were Brexit barriers slowed much more sharply.
Relative to bilateral exports that were not affected by the Brexit barriers, on average, Brexit barriers reduced UK exports of affected services to an EU country that imposes such barriers by 16%.
Global effects
Brexit could also have knock-on effects on how the UK trades with the rest of the world. UK businesses might struggle more globally - or they might pivot and grow elsewhere.
We find these spillover effects to be very small. Whether measuring them directly or adjusting our methodology to remove UK exports to non-EU countries as the reference group for comparison, the story was broadly the same - the UK's global services exports dropped by about 4% to 5% after Brexit.
Germany requires lawyers to have EEA or Swiss qualifications to provide certain legal services
Another notable finding is that barriers to cross-border investment matter just as much as barriers to trade. Many services - especially in finance, life sciences and professional services - are delivered through foreign affiliates, branches or partnerships. Investment frictions have also had significant negative consequences for exports.
A cautionary tale of deglobalisation
Beyond the UK, our study offers a broader lesson: deglobalisation has real economic costs, especially for advanced economies. The idea that regulatory sovereignty and global openness can go hand-in-hand is appealing - but it is difficult to achieve.
Far from unleashing the UK's global services potential, Brexit has slowed it down. Untying that knot will require not just new deals, but a new approach to international engagement - one which recognises that global competitiveness requires resolving complex regulatory frictions that can only be reduced through trust and cooperation among trade partners.
Services barriers explained
What services does the UK export?
The UK is a world-leader in selling expertise - it is the second largest exporter of services in the world after the United States. The UK is particularly strong in financial, insurance, and "other business services" - a trade data category that includes law, accounting, engineering and architecture. It also outperforms global averages in exporting "personal, cultural and recreational services", a category which includes education and health services. And charging for the use of intellectual property, such as UK-produced television shows and films, is another strength. (De Lyon et al, 2022).
How important are services to UK economy?
Services contribute to about 80% of gross value added in the UK and have been the main driver of economic growth, with services making up half of UK exports (Brien, 2023). The share of services in exports is far larger for the UK than any other country of comparable size specialising in services (De Lyon et al, 2022).
What type of barriers exist?
Under the Trade and Cooperation Agreement (TCA), which regulates post-Brexit trade between the UK and EU, the trade in goods is tariff-free but there are non-tariff barriers to trade. Non-tariff barriers in goods include customs checks but in intangibles such as services, these barriers can also include lack of recognition of qualifications across borders, different regulatory standards, the need for a licence, restrictions on the nationality or residency of senior management. While the TCA limits what trade restrictions countries can put in place, it does allow countries to impose restrictions in line with domestic law for certain services. (Bhalotia et al, 2025)
Who has imposed more barriers?
Austria, Bulgaria and Sweden have imposed reservations on more services relative to the other EU countries, while Belgium, Ireland and Netherlands have allowed for freer cross-border trade and investment. (Bhalotia et al, 2025)
Barriers arise from divergent national rules and regulations
This article summarises "Deglobalisation in disguise? Brexit barriers and trade in services" by Shania Bhalotia, Swati Dhingra and Danyal Arnold, CEP Discussion Paper No. 2110. A version of it first appeared as a UK in a Changing Europe blog.
Swati Dhingra is an associate professor of economics at LSE and a research associate in CEP's trade programme. Shania Bhalotia is a PhD candidate in economics at LSE. Danyal Arnold is a legal professional.
Further reading
Brien, P. (2023) Services industries: key economic indicators. House of Commons library
De Lyon, J., Martin, R., Oliveira-Cunha, J., Shah, A., Shah, K., Thwaites, G. and Valero, A. (2022) Enduring strengths: Analysing the UK's current and potential economic strengths, and what they mean for its economic strategy, at the start of the decisive decade. The Economy 2030 Inquiry.
21 October 2025 Paper Number CEPCP714
Download PDF - Deglobalisation in disguise?
This CentrePiece article is published under the centre's Trade programme.
This publication comes under the following theme: Global firms, Brexit, Trade Policy and barriers to international economic integration