Skip to main content

CEP/STICERD Applications Seminars

The informativeness of aggregate differences for individual choices: Theory and Evidence

Harsh Gupta (LSE)

02 November 2026 12:00 - 13:30

This event is both online and in person.

SAL 1.04, 1st Floor Conference Room, Sir Arthur Lewis Building, LSE, 32 Lincoln's Inn Fields, London WC2A 3PH

Online participants are welcome:
Please contact Lia Bergin (Communications and Events Assistant) l.bergin@lse.ac.uk to receive event updates and a link to the seminar online.

About this event

A large literature in health economics and other fields (e.g., education, urban economics) documents aggregate differences in the impact of physicians (teachers, neighborhoods) on randomly assigned patients (students, residents). Whether these aggregates inform an individual?s choice and welfare, such as a physician?s treatment of a specific patient, is not well established. We show theoretically that Counterfactual Homogeneity (CH), a condition we formulate, is necessary and sufficient for aggregate estimates to apply to specific patients. CH requires that counterfactuals can be mapped by a function that is homogeneous across all patients. Testing CH requires estimating the causal effect of different physicians on specific patients, which is difficult with standard datasets and across-subject designs. Using a novel dataset on standardized patients in India, where we observe such patient-level differences in practice, we test CH directly. CH is frequently violated across cases that differ in diagnostic uncertainty. For example, it is violated across patient gender when diagnostic uncertainty is low, but not when it is high. Welfare estimates of policies that reallocate physicians to patients based on aggregate estimates are severely biased when CH is violated. Finally, we provide a statistical test based on over-identification restrictions that lets researchers test CH without standardized patients.


Participants are expected to adhere to the CEP Events Code of Conduct.


Directions

This event will take place in SAL 1.04, 1st Floor Conference Room, Sir Arthur Lewis Building, LSE, 32 Lincoln's Inn Fields, London WC2A 3PH.

Online participants are welcome:
Please contact Lia Bergin (Communications and Events Assistant) l.bergin@lse.ac.uk to receive event updates and a link to the seminar online.

The building is labelled SAL on the LSE campus map. You can also find us on Google Maps. For further information, go to contact us.

This series is part of the CEP's Labour programme.